Class Recaps: ‘Wines in Time’

Ep. 1 – “Inventing Traditional” // Ep. 2 – “Champagne Is Technology” // Ep. 3 – “Born In Clay” // Ep. 4 – “Native Vines” // Ep. 5 – “On A Boat” // Ep. 6 – “What’s Voile Got to Do With It?” // Ep. 7 – “The House Phylloxera Built” // Ep. 8 – “Bordeaux Is A Murder Mystery”

Header image: “The Pyramids of El Geezeh, from the Southwest,” Francis Firth, albumen print made 1857, from the digitized public domain collection of the Art Institute of Chicago.

The image was made using the collodion process: wet, sticky, and fizzing on a glass plate exposed in a portable dark room (“a smothering little tent,” Frith called it). The process had been invented only six years before.

Human had been growing wine for at least four thousand years when the pyramids in this image were being built. (The earliest signs of viticulture in France would not appear until the pyramids at Giza had been standing for another two thousand.)

“Autumn, Vintage Scene” — wool, silk, and gold tapestry designed c. 1535 and woven in the mid-1600s, possibly by Gobelins Manufractory (Paris, est. 1662). From the digital public domain collection of the Cleveland Museum of Art.

Not so long ago, Prosecco was a cloudy pét-nat. Barolo was pink and fizzy. Pinot grigio was the color of rose gold. And Sancerre was red wine.

Regions considered ‘classics’ have often been making wine for a long, long time — but the wine they were making for most of that history might not look much like what we’ve been taught to expect.

When was ‘traditional’ invented? And who’s making wines today that remind us of what came before it?

Further reading: “The Myth of ‘Old World’ Wine”, Punch (Nov, 2020). Interested in what we talked about when we tasted? Buy a recording of the live session here. Details on what we drank below:

“Workers leaving the factory, Thaon-les-Vosges,” anonymous, postcard addressed to Alphonsine Colin (1907). From the digital public domain collection of the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam.

Champagne is a cold, northern winegrowing region. For a long time, it grew pale co-ferments the color of onion skins and partridge eyes.

Champagne is a technology, refined over a hundred years by English shippers and German merchant families. A product of the long 19th century, it was the ultimate modernist beverage: dependent on coal, carried by railroad, advertised in mass-media Art Deco posters, its terroir fertilized with plastic garbage bags and carved up by WWI trenches, its boundaries defined by labor riots.

As a method, its manufacture spread far beyond the region’s borders, from Cincinnati to Ukraine. As a winegrowing region, its growers have been grappling with its contradictions ever since.

Details on what we drank below:

“Mastoid (drinking cup),” attributed to the Leafless Group, depicting Dionysius astride a donkey (Athens, c. 500-480 BCE), from the digital public domain collection of the Art Institute of Chicago.

But how did it all begin?

Vines were domesticated in Central Asia, six or seven thousand years before the grapes on this cup were painted.

Our earliest evidence of winemaking survives as traces on pottery shards in archeological sites scattered through the Caucasus, in caves where clay fermenters were buried below stone grape presses, and in graves where men and women were buried with their drinking horns and clay pots.

In the preset-day Republic of Georgia, long used as a wine factory by the Russian empire, ancestral knowledge was kept alive out in the countryside by home winemakers. Real wine was what you got ladled out of your neighbor’s qvevri; fake wine came in a bottle from one of the factories.

The invasion in 2008 changed everything. And today, as these ancient wines are being revived and celebrated, they are increasingly being made by a new generation of women and outsiders who tradition would have never let in.

Buy a recording of the live interactive session here. Details on what we drank below:

“View of Cotopaxi,” Frederic Edwin Church, oil on canvas (1857). From the public domain collection of the Art Institute of Chicago.

The curator’s text adds, “Inspired by German naturalist Alexander von Humboldt’s concept of ecological interconnectedness, Church traveled to South America to meticulously study the tropical landscape … The painting likewise reflected an imperial vision, as U.S. government officials eyed Latin America as a site for territorial expansion and conquest.”

The history of winegrowing in the ‘New World’ doesn’t start in Napa, or with European vines. It has its roots in Mapuche fruit fermentations and North Carolina forests. It encompasses dozens of vine species that are native to the Americas, and goes back half a millennium.

From hybrid wines to own-rooted criollas, and from southern Chile to the Appalachian Mountains, we explored what it means to be a grape variety called ‘native to a region’, and tasted bottles that retell the story of American wine.

Buy a recording of the live interactive session here. Details on what we drank below:

“The Plantation,” ca. 1825, artist unknown. Oil on wood, possibly based on a needlework design. From the digital public domain collection of the Met’s American wing.

What happens when a wine becomes a luxury good traded overseas, instead of a food grown at home?

For Madeira, beloved of the Founding Fathers, it meant intentional sweetness, fortification with brandy, oxidation like a cut apple left out on a kitchen counter, cooking in the holds of slave-trading ships setting sail from Cape Coast Castle.

(After its journey, it would be served to those devotees at establishments like the Charleston Jockey Club, opened, tasted, and poured by the enslaved Black men who were the first sommeliers in the United States.)

Madeira is a unique wine from a unique place: a volcanic island off the coast of Africa that was deforested, then used for sugarcane production until the soil gave out, then terraformed into vineyard land growing varieties that today exist nowhere else in the world.

But, as a wine, it’s also just the most famous survivor of what was done to almost any wine that ended up on boats.

At the speed of oar or sale, if wine was traded, it was altered to survive the journey: pine resin, honey, herbs, salt water, lead.

Until the middle of the 19th century, Bordeaux was fortified with brandy and Spanish grape juice to endure the Channel crossing. Wines like sack, jerez, canary, and marsala were king. It was impossible to taste the sorts of fragile homemade wines we celebrate now outside of the back yard of the farmer who grew them.

“The Wine Connoisseurs,” Jacob Duck of Utrecht (c. 1640-1642), oil on panel, from the digital public domain collection of the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam.

Palomino is a grape that was put to work. Most famous for the vintage-blended, fortified, often sweetened sherries of Jerez that fueled the British empire, it also found itself in a lot of other places it’d been brought to by ships or autocrats.

(A few of those places: the Canary Islands, where it accompanied the Conquista under the name listan blanco; Galicia, in the wake of phylloxera, later to be encouraged by Franco; Cyprus, where it was used to bolster production of ‘Cyprus sherry’—by the 1960s, the British were drinking over 13 million liters per year of the stuff.)

Like a lot of workhorse varieties, what palomino can do has often been obscured by what it’s been made to do.

We peeled back the veil (literally and figuratively) to see what else these wines had to say.

Buy a recording of the live interactive session here. Details on what we drank below:

“The Eruption of Vesuvius,” Pierre-Jacques Volaire (1771), oil on canvas, from the digital public domain collection of the Art Institute of Chicago. “Vesuvius erupted six times between 1707 and 1794, and thus became a touchstone of popular culture at the time.”

The landscape of modern wine, the regions and grape varieties we take for granted, was in a lot of ways invented by the mass extinction event of phylloxera at the end of the 19th century.

Phylloxera is a pale yellow, sap-sucking aphid. Endemic to the eastern United States, whose local vine species have evolved accomodations to its predations, its arrival in Europe in the late 1850s began a slow-motion ecological catastrophe: first the Languedoc, then France, then Europe, then the world.

It’s why almost every wine you’ve ever tasted has been amde from vines grafted onto rootstocks not their own. It’s why there are fewer than 300 hectares of scattered plots under vine in Isère, between the Savoie and the Northern Rhône, instead of 33,000. It’s why Rioja became a commercial wine region, bankrolled by Bordeaux money looking for alternative looking for an alternative to their dying vines.

And phylloxera was only the latest and worst of a series of crises caused by faster transportation, international trade, and ecosystem collapse—which makes its lessons much more than just academic for today’s winegrowers.

What was it like, the world we lost to the louse?

Buy a recording of the live interactive session here. Details on what we drank below:

“French Dining Room of the Louis XIV Period, 1660-1700,” Narcissa Niblack Thorne, miniature room scaled 1 inch to 1 foot (c. 1937) from the digital public domain collection of the Art Institute of Chicago.

Bordeaux is, without question, luxury wine’s greatest success story. It is the largest fine wine region on the planet, at more than 200,000 hectares under vine. For the last two hundred years, it’s had a stranglehold on the concept of ‘fine wine’ itself.

Its rise, first as a mercantile juggernaut, then as a winegrowing region in its own right, was built on the bones of places it got rich off of and then destroyed, from Buzet to Gaillac.

But up in the hill country, the survivors of the Sud-Ouest may have their own version of the story: medieval market towns perched on navigable rivers that empty into the Atlantic, with local specialties, native vines, and nearly forgotten winemaking traditions that date back as far as the Romans…

Buy a recording of the live interactive session here. Details on what we drank below:

Leave a comment